I thought it would be nice to have a more positive immigration story, in this case 22 immigrants sworn in through the long and difficult citizenship process. A small number in the face of modern immigration.
One of the new citizens was a child when he was first brought from Mexico into the states by his parents, which reminded me of the discussion about children who were taken across the border by their parents, thus had no way of determining their own fate but were still punished for the actions of their parents.
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Mass criminal immigration hearings unlawful
The article here talks about the efforts of an Arizona federal court trying to speed up the hearing process on illegal immigration. Rather than hearing each defendant individually, the court chose to use a mass hearing, putting large groups of defendants in the room and asking them if they understood the rights read to them. However the local court of appeals ruled that this format made it difficult for the defendants to understand what was being asked of them and constituted a violation of court procedure and the mass hearings had to be discontinued.
It's interesting to note that the appeal judges, while ruling against the practice, stated that they understood the underlying reason for it. The Arizona court was overwhelmed with immigration cases and attempted to speed things along. The appeals court recognized the need for it, but found that it violated the rules all the same. This is illustrative of how the immigration system as it is now has become a major burden on the U.S. legal system, and without reform from above, local courts are forced to enact improvised systems that risk circumventing the rights of the defendant.
It's interesting to note that the appeal judges, while ruling against the practice, stated that they understood the underlying reason for it. The Arizona court was overwhelmed with immigration cases and attempted to speed things along. The appeals court recognized the need for it, but found that it violated the rules all the same. This is illustrative of how the immigration system as it is now has become a major burden on the U.S. legal system, and without reform from above, local courts are forced to enact improvised systems that risk circumventing the rights of the defendant.
Shifiting the focus of Immigration Enforcement Policy?
In what appears to be a change in the methodology of immigration enforcement, the Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiative (commonly referred to as ICE) has announced an "audit" of 1,000 different companies, looking at whether or not these enterprises knowingly hire illegal immigrants. At first glance, this seems to be a change in tactics. As pointed out in the article, normal fare for ICE consisted of mounting raids at work places, looking for undocumented workers. These raids seem to have placed priority on immigrants rather than offending businesses. These new tactics seem to be a reversal of this. However, the article points out that the list of businesses being targeted are not being publicly named. Furthermore, while 1,000 different businesses are certainly not a trivial number, I wonder if these audits are only scratching the surface. What types of business are the audits targeting? Do they represent the traditional, large scale employers of illegal immigrants such as the agriculture industry, or service industries (as the article suggests)? Do the 1,000 business as a whole target a certain business, and target a significant quantity of such businesses, or is the selection random, or not target a meaningful number of enterprises? The thrust of my questioning leads to one overarching concern; is this a meaningful gesture or not? If this "audit" does not target the traditional employers of illegal immigrants, or does not target a significant market share (that is, if the audit doesn't do enough "damage" to employers of illegal immigrants in general), then it seems to me that this action is a meaningless gesture. Whether or not this is the case, the audits are having an impact in the behavior in companies. For example, the article states that a clothing manufacture dismissed over 1/4 of its work force (~1,800 employees) after an audit raised concern over its hiring practices regarding illegals. The business community as a whole, the article goes on to state, is reacting as a whole. However, how comprehensive and what the longevity of this reaction has yet to be seen, as this is only the second audit of its kind to be conducted.
Russia vs. Georgia
This is probably the most ridiculous cartoon I found. The US has no control over the borders, who crosses or even how many illegal immigrants are currently living in the states and definitely we should send our troops to defend another country in a matter that we have our hands full with. There is no need for the US to get involved in another international fight that has nothing to do with our safety without first fixing the internal problems that we have been experiencing for the past decades.
Immigration cartoons
http://www.cartoonstock.com/newscartoons/directory/I/Immigration.asp
I was looking through different websites and came across this one. All of the cartoons displayed on the link are funny. The first one struck me the most. Since I used to live in Miami, marrying somebody for their papers is a common situation there. It is known that a lot of Cubans and Puerto Ricans will marry hispanics that need papers for about 5000 dollars, and the funny thing is that the Immigration Office thinks it is official because it is a marriage between two Hispanics. I do not know how common it is among other nationalities but in Miami there are even "brokers" who will literally "hook you up" with a person and a believable story and receive money after you get your papers... it is an incredible business.
I was looking through different websites and came across this one. All of the cartoons displayed on the link are funny. The first one struck me the most. Since I used to live in Miami, marrying somebody for their papers is a common situation there. It is known that a lot of Cubans and Puerto Ricans will marry hispanics that need papers for about 5000 dollars, and the funny thing is that the Immigration Office thinks it is official because it is a marriage between two Hispanics. I do not know how common it is among other nationalities but in Miami there are even "brokers" who will literally "hook you up" with a person and a believable story and receive money after you get your papers... it is an incredible business.
New Phone Apps
The Readers Digest version of this story is that students from University of California have developed an application for Nextel phones. The application will show immigrants illegally crossing the border where to go for water, major roads, and border patrol officials should they be too weak to continue their journey. They are doing this as a project for a humanitarian class. The application will be preloaded into an unspecified number of phones that will be delivered to Mexico as part of their humanitarian project.
I am torn on how I feel about this. Because the application does not directly give immigrants entry points, there is nothing technically wrong with the project. However, it is still giving aid to people coming in illegally.
On the other hand, it is terrible that these imigrants are "forced" to come across the border illegally because our policies take too long. It is also terrible that many of these immigrants are seriously injured or even killed as a result of their journey.
The application seems on the surface to he more help than it is harm. The government could even use the GPS in the devices to crack down on illegal immigration. Therefore, right off I believe I am in favor of the application. Because illegal immigration is not going to stop any time in the near future, I believe that we should do what we can to help others in need.
I am torn on how I feel about this. Because the application does not directly give immigrants entry points, there is nothing technically wrong with the project. However, it is still giving aid to people coming in illegally.
On the other hand, it is terrible that these imigrants are "forced" to come across the border illegally because our policies take too long. It is also terrible that many of these immigrants are seriously injured or even killed as a result of their journey.
The application seems on the surface to he more help than it is harm. The government could even use the GPS in the devices to crack down on illegal immigration. Therefore, right off I believe I am in favor of the application. Because illegal immigration is not going to stop any time in the near future, I believe that we should do what we can to help others in need.
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
Language preservation among Cambodian-Americans
This is a short article about attempts at Khmer (Cambodian)-language preservation in the San Francisco Bay area. The Bay area has a relatively large Cambodian community, which really began during the 1980's after the Cambodian genocide ended. I thought this acticle would be interesting, because it is about a relatively small immigrant group in the US, and how they are trying to hold onto their ethnic identity. Cambodia itself is small. A huge majority of Cambodians are ethnically Khmer and Khmer is a distinct language. We've talked a little bit in class about the role of Spanish in preserving Latino culture, and its something I'm discussing in my final project also. But imagine how difficult it is to preserve Khmer language among American-born Khmers. Outside of a few urban communities, Khmer has no presence in the US and worldwide, the way some other languages like Spanish, French and Chinese do. Aside from ethnic pride, and wanting to be able to communicate with family back in Cambodia, there is no benefit to knowing Khmer.
In my opinion, Khmer culture is typical of most Southeast Asian cultures. It is Bhuddist, its traditional food, music, dance and martial arts are very similar to those if Thialand and Vietnam. BUT, most Khmers would insist on the their distinction. Language seems like the most obvious way for Khmers in America to not only maintain their Southeast Asian culture, but their more distinct Khmer culture. But because Khmer-Americans are such a small, marginalized group, maintaining their language, and in effect their distinct ethnicity, is difficult.
So I guess I'm just trying to point out this difficult situation that not only Khmer-Americans, but I'm sure many other immigrant groups, face in preserving their ethnic identity in the America.
In my opinion, Khmer culture is typical of most Southeast Asian cultures. It is Bhuddist, its traditional food, music, dance and martial arts are very similar to those if Thialand and Vietnam. BUT, most Khmers would insist on the their distinction. Language seems like the most obvious way for Khmers in America to not only maintain their Southeast Asian culture, but their more distinct Khmer culture. But because Khmer-Americans are such a small, marginalized group, maintaining their language, and in effect their distinct ethnicity, is difficult.
So I guess I'm just trying to point out this difficult situation that not only Khmer-Americans, but I'm sure many other immigrant groups, face in preserving their ethnic identity in the America.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)